In the podcast episode "Rankings are Dumb: Why Michelin Stars are a Double-Edged Sword and You Shouldn't Be All-In on Lists," Nick & Chris discuss the impact of restaurant rankings, particularly the prestigious Michelin star rating system.
What one person may consider a delicious and exceptional meal may not meet the same criteria for another person.
This subjectivity is compounded by the fact that the Michelin guide's inspectors are anonymous and their criteria for awarding stars is not publicly disclosed, leading to speculation and debate about the guide's fairness and accuracy.
But, there are downsides to being awarded a Michelin Star.
While a star can bring in new business and boost a restaurant's reputation, the pressure to maintain that star can be intense and overwhelming for restaurant owners and chefs.
The cost of ingredients, staff, and other expenses can also increase due to a star, potentially leading to price hikes for customers.
Research suggests that restaurants with Michelin stars may be more likely to prioritize the technical execution of a dish over the overall dining experience and atmosphere.
Another issue with ranking systems like the Michelin guide is that they can perpetuate a certain type of dining culture and exclude other types of cuisine.
The guide has been criticized for its lack of diversity in terms of both the types of restaurants it covers and the inspectors who determine the ratings.
This narrow focus can lead to a homogenization of the dining scene and a lack of representation for more diverse and local food cultures.
Like Michelin Stars, reliance on rankings can lead to a blindness of sorts.
While it can be helpful to have some guidance in choosing a restaurant or other service, it's important to remember that these rankings are just one person's or group's opinion and should not be the sole factor in making a decision.
It's crucial to also consider personal preferences and do one's own research before making a final choice.
While they can be a useful resource, it's important to remember that they are subjective and to not put too much stock in any one ranking.
It's always worth doing one's own research and considering personal preferences when making decisions about where to eat or what services to use.
Comments